Cold Email vs LinkedIn Message: Which one is a better for 2025?

Cold Email vs LinkedIn Message

B2B Prospecting usually involves two main contenders: LinkedIn messages and Cold emailing. Both have their perks when reaching out to decision-makers, but which one is more suitable? 

It’s like choosing coffee or tea, both have their distinct flavors. 

This article will help you choose one of these for your prospecting. Let’s begin

Why Cold Email For Outbound Outreach?

There is something powerful about landing in someone’s inbox, isn’t it? Cold emailing is a trustworthy way of B2B outreach and according to a recent study by Hubspot : 

“81% of B2B marketers still rank email as their most effective channel for demand generation”

You must be wondering what makes cold email effective. The answer is its scalability. You can use different automation tools and reach thousands of prospects while maintaining the personal touch. Ryan Deiss has something to say about it : 

“ Email is still the most valuable real estate in marketing. It’s the only place where people, not algorithms, make the rules”

Yes, you heard it right, you got the right platform here.

However, there are some elements that you need to consider including, spam filters and inbox competition. Spam filters are getting smarter and inbox competition is fierce.

An average professional receives 121 emails per day. Now standing out requires more creativity than ever. But remember, cold emailing delivers consistent results when done right. 

80% of buyers prefer getting pitched via email, and a whopping 59% of B2B pros consider it their top revenue-generating channel. While the average response rate hovers around 4.1% , yes that’s concerning. You need to be creative. 

Pros

  1. Scalability
  • Automate hundreds or thousands of personalized outreach attempts
  • Easy to A/B test different approaches
  • Systematic follow-up sequences

 

  1. Cost-Effectiveness
  • Lower cost per contact compared to other channels
  • Minimal infrastructure requirements
  • Easy to scale up or down based on needs

 

  1. Rich Analytics
  • Detailed tracking of open rates, click rates, and response rates
  • Easy A/B testing capabilities
  • Clear ROI measurement

 

  1. Flexibility
  • Long-form content capability
  • Ability to include attachments and rich media
  • Custom HTML formatting options

Cons

  1. Deliverability Challenges
  • Spam filters becoming increasingly sophisticated
  • Domain reputation management required
  • Regular warm-up needed for new domains

 

  1. Competition for Attention
  • Average professional receives 120+ emails daily
  • Lower average response rates compared to LinkedIn
  • Requires exceptional content to stand out

 

  1. Legal Compliance
  • Must adhere to the CAN-SPAM Act
  • GDPR compliance for European prospects
  • Regular list cleaning required

 

Things to follow

  1. Personalization

   

   BAD: “Dear Sir/Madam, I wanted to reach out about our services…”

   GOOD: “Hi {FirstName}, Noticed you recently expanded your team at {Company}…”

   

  1. Subject Line Optimization
  • Keep it under 60 characters
  • Use personalization tokens
  • Create curiosity without clickbait

   

   Examples of good subject lines:

   – Quick question about {Company}’s {specific challenge}

   – {Mutual connection} suggested I reach out

   – Ideas for {specific goal} at {Company}

 

  1. Email Structure
  • Opening: Personalized context (1-2 sentences)
  • Value proposition: Clear benefit statement (1-2 sentences)
  • Proof: Case study or specific results (1-2 sentences)
  • Call to action: Clear, low-commitment ask (1 sentence)

 

  1. Follow-up Strategy
  • 5-7 touch sequence
  • 3-5 days between emails
  • Vary messaging and approach in each follow-up

 

Things to Avoid

– Mass generic blasts

– Long paragraphs

– Multiple CTAs

– Aggressive sales language

– False urgency

– Deceptive subject lines

Why LinkedIn Messages For Outbound Outreach?

LinkedIn messages are like having a conversation at a professional networking event. There’s context, visible social proof, and a more immediate sense of connection. There are over 900 million professionals and 63 million decision-makers on LinkedIn, which makes it a good fit for business relationships. There is something personal about LinkedIn. Prospect can see your face, your role, or your background before starting the conversation. 

4 out of 5 B2B leads come through LinkedIn, and it’s clear that professionals are finding real value in this network’s targeted, relationship-driven approach to business development.

Pros

  1. Built-in Social Proof
  • Professional profiles provide immediate credibility
  • Mutual connections visible
  • Company and career history accessible

 

  1. Superior Targeting
  • Advanced search filters
  • Company Targeting
  • Job title and seniority filtering.

 

  1. Higher Engagement
  • Messages appear more personal
  • Push notifications on mobile
  • Higher trust factor

 

  1. Network Building
  • Long-term relationship potential
  • Easy to engage with prospect’s content
  • Natural conversation flow

 

Cons

  1. Scale Limitations
  • Connection request limits
  • Message limits for free accounts
  • Higher cost for Sales Navigator

 

  1. Platform Dependency
  • Subject to LinkedIn’s algorithm changes
  • Account restrictions risk
  • Limited customization options

 

  1. Cost Considerations
  • Premium subscriptions required for full features
  • Higher cost per contact than email
  • Additional tools needed for automation

 

Things to follow

  1. Profile Optimization
  • Professional photo
  • Compelling headline
  • Detailed experience section
  • Regular content posting

 

  1. Connection Strategy
  • Personalized connection requests
  • Engage with content before connecting
  • Mutual connection leverage.

 

  1. Message Structure

   GOOD EXAMPLE:

   “Hi {FirstName},

   

   Your recent post about {specific topic} caught my attention. The approach you described for {specific challenge} aligns with what we’ve been seeing in the industry.

   Would you be open to a quick chat about how we’ve helped companies like {reference company} achieve {specific result}?

   Best,

   {Your name}”

 

  1. Engagement Sequence
  • Like and comment on content
  • Send connection request
  • Wait for acceptance
  • Send initial message
  • Follow up with value

 

Things to Avoid

– Generic connection requests

– Immediate sales pitches

– Automated message sequences

– Overly formal language

– Spammy behavior

– Excessive follow-ups

 

Cold Email + LinkedIn Message: The Multi-Channel Approach

Here is the plot twist – most successful B2B outreach strategies don’t pick one of them, they benefit from both of them at the same time. You can use LinkedIn to warm up relationships and then email for detailed conversations and formal proposals.

‘’ Multi-channel approaches generate 287% more prospects than single-channel campaigns’’

You must understand when to use each of them.

  1. Use LinkedIn when you want to:
  • Build relationship capital before pitching
  • Leverage mutual connections
  • Share valuable content and engage with prospects’ posts
  • Target specific decision-makers with precision

 

  1. Turn to cold email when you need to:
  • Scale your outreach efforts
  • Send detailed proposals or pitches
  • Follow up systematically
  • Track engagement metrics more precisely

 

Whether you’re sliding into LinkedIn DMs or crafting the perfect email subject line, generic messages are dead on arrival. Make sure your messages don’t feel robotic. Buyers expect the conversation to be genuine and authentic. The secret sauce? Personalization and timing.

Your prospects aren’t just LinkedIn profiles or inbox addresses, they are real people who are looking for real solutions. The channel you choose matters less than the value you provide. 

Integration Strategy

  1. Initial Touch
  • LinkedIn: View profile 
  • LinkedIn: Engage with content
  • Email: First contact

   

  1. Follow-up Sequence
  • LinkedIn: Connection request
  • Email: Second touch
  • LinkedIn: Message
  • Email: Final follow-up

 

Synchronization Tips

– Use consistent messaging across channels

– Track touches in CRM

– Maintain appropriate timing between touches

– Personalize approach based on engagement

Key Takeaways

  1. Choose based on your:
  • Target audience
  • Resource availability
  • Scale requirements
  • Content type

 

  1. Success Factors:
  • Personalization is non-negotiable
  • Value-first approach
  • Consistent follow-up
  • Clear call-to-action

 

  1. Best Practices:
  • Test both channels
  • Monitor metrics
  • Optimize based on data
  • Maintain a professional presence

 

FAQs

Q1. What’s the ideal length considered for a cold email?

A. Make it concise. Keep the initial email between 50-125 words. Focus on one clear message and call to action.

Q2. How many follow-ups should I need to send?

A. Cold Email: 5-7 touches over 2-3 weeks, 

LinkedIn: 2-3 touches over 1-2 weeks

Q3. What’s the best time to send outreach messages?

A.  Email: Tuesday-Thursday, 10 AM-2 PM recipient’s local time

– LinkedIn Business hours, with higher engagement rates on Wednesday and Thursday

Q4. How do I keep track of things?

A. Track these key metrics:

  • Response rates
  • Meeting booking rates
  • Conversion to opportunity
  • Cost per meeting booked
  • ROI per channel

Q5. How do I maintain compliance?

A. You can follow these things ;

  • Follow CAN-SPAM Act guidelines
  • Respect GDPR
  • Include unsubscribe options
  • Maintain accurate records
  • Regular list cleaning

 

B2B outreach strategies in 2025 typically combine both cold email and LinkedIn messaging in a coordinated, multi-channel approach. If you want a good outreach, you should not be meddling in the cold email vs LinkedIn messages thing. Use both of them to get more outcomes. Use the strengths of each channel while considering their weaknesses through careful planning, consistent monitoring, and continuous optimization. Good luck with your outreach.

© 2024 Slyleadz, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Twitter Linkedin